Skip to main content
guest
Join
|
Help
|
Sign In
Grade8Elpat
Home
guest
|
Join
|
Help
|
Sign In
Wiki Home
Recent Changes
Pages and Files
Members
Grade8Elpat
Home
Bill Ideas
Debate Topics
Debating
House Bill 1 - Standardized testing
House Bill 2 - illegal immigrant
House Bill 3 - Military
House Bill 4 - Metric System
House Bill 5 - Outsourcing
Melissa and Eliza
Resources
Main Elpat Page
House Bill 2 - illegal immigrant
Edit
0
9
…
1
Tags
index
Notify
RSS
Backlinks
Source
Print
Export (PDF)
Pro
Con
The state will receive more taxes for various things
how would you know if they're illegal or not?
In states where illegal immigrants are very populous, citizens may be able to pay a smaller portion of taxes.
Theyd have to become a citizen to pay taxes
Can't be arrested by IRS if paying taxes
This is basically allowing the US to have illegal immigrants.
Actually make living in the U.S. more fair.
It's technically illegal because all illegal immigrants must be deported
Scource:
http://www.uscis.gov/
How do you fine a person who doesn't have enough money to pay taxes?
Pro Con debate for this topic
http://immigration.procon.org/view.answers.php?questionID=000789
Notes from Google Drive:
Pro
Con
We would have more tax dollars to support our facilities, organizations, etc.
How will they find illegal aliens if they do not have the countries authorization
They are basically paying towards their arrest which is beneficial for america because it supports the government
Incorrect spelling of the word sums: spelled somes
Immigration reform will make the federal budget situation better
Incorrect definition of american citizens
Immigrants will have to provide some form of identification when paying these taxes, making them easier to identify.
Even when paying taxes they are still illegal immigrants
Immigrants are working for free basically, so it’ll give the government more money for their work.
Confusion of Labor and Human Resources Services
It will make it harder to find illegal immigrants because people will assume they are american citizens because they are paying taxes
So why can’t they pay the rest of the taxes?
Within 18 months illegal immigrants can become legalized.
Prejudice- if one blue person is illegal, all blue people in america will be considered illegal
Why fine if illegal? They should be sent back their original country.
Incorrect definition of Illegal Aliens
it is difficult to point out illegal immigrants verse legal immigrants
illegal immigrants will hide better and try harder to stay away from police if they know they have to pay taxes
You have totally left out all naturalized citizens.
It would cost more money to track down the illegal aliens than the government would make collecting taxes.
About half to three-fourths of illegal aliens in pay federal, state, and local taxes already and when the buy gas, clothes, or new appliances.
waste of time, money, and resources
is basically just acceptance of illegal immigrants crossing the border unlawfully
how would you know if they
’
e illegal or not?
Theyd have to become a citizen to pay taxes
This is basically allowing the US to have illegal immigrants.
It's technically illegal because all illegal immigrants must be deported
Illegal immigrants barely have enough money to begin with.
Thats wasting all the hard labor they do just to support themselves
How do you fine a person who doesn't have enough money to pay taxes?
Javascript Required
You need to enable Javascript in your browser to edit pages.
help on how to format text
Turn off "Getting Started"
Home
...
Loading...
Pro Con debate for this topic
http://immigration.procon.org/view.answers.php?questionID=000789
Notes from Google Drive: